Science advances - 저자에게 요구하는 확인사항

논문 출판 전 확인사항 

 

We appreciate your cooperation in completing our Authorship and Conflicts of Interest form. A response is required for every question. You may save information and return to this form at any time. The form is not visible to the editorial office until it is submitted. Submission of this form is achieved by clicking the Save and Submit button at the end of the form. Completion of this form is required prior to acceptance. We encourage immediate completion of this form so any issues can be addressed while the manuscript is still being processed. Please make sure all author contributions, funding, competing interests, and any constraints on data and materials availability have been or will be provided to your corresponding author and are or will be reflected in all drafts of your manuscript.

Please indicate your contribution on this article, using the dropdown CRediT taxonomy of roles. If already present in your manuscript files, below are the roles identified by our system, which you may edit/remove. Please click and save all that apply.

Contributor Roles

 

Add

• Conceptualization
• Data curation
• Formal analysis
• Investigation
• Methodology
• Validation
• Writing - original draft

1. Authorship

Authorship Criteria

Authors in Science Journals must fulfill the criteria described below that are informed by the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors definition of authorship. Specifically,

• Each author is expected to have made substantial contributions to the conception or design of the work;
• OR the acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of data;
• OR creation of new software used in the work;
• OR have drafted the work or substantially revised it;
• AND has approved the submitted version (and any substantially modified version that involves the author’s contribution to the study;
• AND agrees to be personally accountable for the author’s own contributions and for ensuring that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any part of the work, even ones in which the author was not personally involved, are appropriately investigated, resolved, and documented in the literature.

I meet the criteria for authorship as defined above

Yes

No

Corresponding Author Responsibilities

• Ensure that all listed authors have received and approved the manuscript prior to submission, and fulfill the authorship criteria listed above.
• Receive all substantive correspondence with editors as well as full reviews.
• Verify that all data, materials (including reagents), and code, even those developed/provided by other authors, comply with the transparency and reproducibility standards of both the field and the journal.
• Ensure that original data/materials/code upon which the submission is based are preserved and retrievable for reanalysis
• Confirm that the presentation in the paper of the data/materials/code accurately reflects the original.
• Foresee and minimize obstacles to the sharing of data/materials/code
• Ensure the entire author group is fully aware of and in compliance with best practices.
• Operational responsibilities, including signing off on galleys, vouching for other authors where necessary, ensuring all authors complete the COI declaration and license forms.

Select one of the following statements:

I am not a corresponding author

I am a corresponding author on a perspective or book review that does not include data/materials/code

I am a corresponding author and I agree to the responsibilities listed above

I am a corresponding author but I can't agree to assume the responsibilities for the following reasons:

2. Contributions

I contributed to this manuscript as listed below:

Ideas; formulation or evolution of overarching research goals and aims.

Yes

No

Development or design of methodology; creation of models.

Yes

No

Programming, software development; designing computer programs; implementation of the computer code and supporting algorithms; testing of existing code components.

Yes

No

Verification, whether as a part of the activity or separate, of the overall replication/reproducibility of results/experiments and other research outputs.

Yes

No

Application of statistical, mathematical, computational, or other formal techniques to analyze or synthesize study data.

Yes

No

Conducting a research and investigation process, specifically performing the experiments, or data/evidence collection.

Yes

No

Provision of study materials, reagents, materials, patients, laboratory samples, animals, instrumentation, computing resources, or other analysis tools.

Yes

No

Management activities to annotate (produce metadata), scrub data and maintain research data (including software code, where it is necessary for interpreting the data itself) for initial use and later reuse.

Yes

No

Creation and/or presentation of the published work, specifically writing the initial draft (including substantive translation).

Yes

No

Preparation, creation and/or presentation of the published work by those from the original research group, specifically critical review, commentary or revision – including pre- or post-publication stages.

Yes

No

Preparation, creation and/or presentation of the published work, specifically visualization/data presentation.

Yes

No

Oversight and leadership responsibility for the research activity planning and execution, including mentorship external to the core team.

Yes

No

Management and coordination responsibility for the research activity planning and execution.

Yes

No

Acquisition of the financial support for the project leading to this publication.

Yes

No

3. Conflict of Interest Disclosure:

All authors must disclose their own affiliations, funding sources, or financial holdings that might be perceived as sources of bias so that readers can evaluate the data and opinions presented in Science journals. Authors’ disclosure of financial and other interests provides transparency. To achieve transparency in this regard, all published research and commentary articles are accompanied by a statement that clearly discloses all interests that may be perceived to be at odds with unbiased presentation of data or analysis.

Current institutional affiliations: Affiliations on the title page should include the current academic, corporate, and/or industrial affiliations of all authors.

All my affiliations are listed on the title page of the paper.

I have additional affiliations that are disclosed in the acknowledgments.

I have additional affiliations that I will provide to the corresponding author for inclusion in the final version. They are included in the disclosure statement at the end of this form.

Funding Sources, including in-kind contributions

I did not contribute funding to this study.

All my sources of funding for this study are listed in the acknowledgement section of the paper.

Additional funding sources not noted in the manuscript have been provided to the corresponding author for inclusion in the final version. They are included in the disclosure statement at the end of this form.

Financial Relationships: Authors must disclose if they have any significant financial interest (equity holdings or stock options) in any corporate entity dealing with the material or the subject matter of this contribution.

I have no financial interests to disclose.

I have financial interests listed in the acknowledgment section of the paper.

I have financial interests not noted in the manuscript that have been provided to the corresponding author for inclusion in the final version. They are included in the disclosure statement at the end of this form.

Management/Advisory affiliations/ Paid Consulting: Authors must disclose if within the last 3 years they have served as an officer, a member of the Board, or a member of an Advisory Committee for any entity engaged in activity related to the subject matter of this contribution and/or have received consulting fees, honoraria, speaking fees, or expert testimony fees from any entity engaged in activity related to the subject matter of this contribution.

I have no management/advisory affiliations/paid consulting to declare.

I have management/advisory affiliations/paid consulting listed in the acknowledgment section of the paper.

I have management/advisory affiliations/paid consulting activities not noted in the manuscript that have been provided to the corresponding author for inclusion in the final version. They are included in the disclosure statement at the end of this form.

Patents: Authors must disclose if they are an inventor on any planned, pending, or awarded patent on this work.

I have no patent applications or pending or awarded patents to declare.

I have patent applications or pending or awarded patents listed in the acknowledgment section of the paper.

I have patent applications or pending or awarded patents not noted in the manuscript that have been provided to the corresponding author for inclusion in the final version. They are included in the disclosure statement at the end of this form.

4. Data Policies:

I affirm that all data necessary for a reader to understand and evaluate the conclusions of the paper are provided in the manuscript and supplementary material or are archived in an approved public database. The name of the database and accession numbers are included in the data accessibility statement in the acknowledgment section.

Not applicable as this is a commentary piece and does not include data.

Yes, I affirm.

No, I can't affirm compliance I defer to the senior author on this question.

No, I can't affirm compliance due to the constraints listed below.

The senior author from each lab or group must have personally checked all the original data that was generated by her/his lab or group.

Not applicable as this is a commentary piece and does not include data.

I am not a senior author.

I am a senior author representing a lab or group and have checked all the original data that were generated by my lab. The data generated by my team are presented in the figures and tables (including Supplementary Material) listed:

I am a senior author and I have not checked all the original data that were generated by my lab for the following reasons:

5. Materials sharing:

I affirm that after publication, all reasonable requests for materials, data and code will be fulfilled.

Not applicable as this is a commentary piece.

Yes, I affirm.

No, I don't affirm. I am not a senior author and do not have control of materials, data or code.

No, I can't affirm due to the constraints listed below.

Materials Transfer Agreements (MTAs). The senior author from each lab or group must disclose whether there are any restrictions associated with the materials or code that was used by her/his lab or group, for example if materials are subject to a MTA.

Not applicable as this is a commentary piece.

I am not a senior author

I am a senior author representing a lab or group and I affirm there are not MTAs or restrictive patents.

I am a senior author and there are MTAs or other restrictions on the use of materials and code. I have provided a copy of the MTA or details of any restrictions to the editorial office. Details of the restrictions have been provided to the corresponding author and are disclosed in the acknowledgments.

I am a senior author and there are MTAs, but I have not provided the agreement for the following reason:

6. Summary Declaration:

I confirm that I have read all the questions, responded to the best of my ability, and provided information as required. In addition, all my declarable relationships are either currently in the acknowledgment or have been provided to the corresponding author. The relationships are listed below for inclusion in the final version of the paper.

This form was submitted on 05-Jan-2023

By typing your name below, you are signing this form electronically.

*Signature: